Merrell All Out Rush Review: Current Trail Shoe Replacements

The Merrell All Out Rush was a trail running shoe for runners and hikers who wanted grip, outdoor durability, and a more nimble feel than a hiking boot. It sat in the active trail lane, not the road running lane. If you are searching for it today, you probably want a current trail shoe that can handle dirt, rocks, and mixed outdoor routes.

Current Merrell trail options have moved on. Agility Peak is the most obvious cushioned trail lane. Trail Glove is the minimalist trail lane. MTL shoes serve more performance-oriented trail runners. HOKA Speedgoat, Brooks Cascadia, Salomon Sense Ride, and ASICS trail shoes are also useful if Merrell fit or ride does not work.

Quick Verdict

The All Out Rush should be treated as a legacy trail reference. Merrell Agility Peak is the first current Merrell model to compare if you want cushion and trail protection. Trail Glove belongs on the list if you want a lower, more minimal feel. MTL models are worth checking for more serious trail intent. HOKA Speedgoat, Brooks Cascadia, Salomon Sense Ride, and ASICS trail shoes provide broader comparison points.

Old All Out Rush stock can be risky because outsole rubber, adhesives, and midsoles age. A current trail shoe is usually safer unless you find a genuinely new, returnable pair at a very low price.

Who The All Out Rush Made Sense For

This shoe made sense for people who wanted something more trail-ready than a road trainer but less bulky than a hiking boot. It could work for light trail running, fast hiking, park trails, and outdoor fitness. It was not the best choice for long road runs or people who need a structured stability shoe.

The replacement should reflect your terrain. Hardpack and gravel call for a different shoe than rocky mountain trails. Mud calls for a different outsole than dry dirt. If your route changes often, a versatile trail daily trainer is the safest starting point.

Current Alternatives

Trail Runner Or Hiking Shoe?

A trail runner is lighter and more flexible than a hiking shoe. That makes it better for running and fast hiking, but it may offer less ankle coverage and less load-carrying support. If you are carrying a heavy pack or walking rocky trails slowly, a hiking shoe may make sense. If you move quickly and want a shoe that transitions well, a trail runner is often better.

Minimal Or Cushioned?

Merrell has both minimal and cushioned trail identities. Trail Glove is not a direct replacement for every All Out Rush shopper. If you want protection and cushioning, start with Agility Peak instead. If you specifically want ground feel and foot strength work, then Trail Glove belongs in the conversation.

What To Check Before Buying Old Stock

Check lug depth, rubber condition, upper tears, midsole compression, and return policy. Trail shoes can look clean in photos while the outsole is already rounded down. If grip is your reason for buying, the lugs need to be healthy.

Best Buying Path

Start with Merrell Agility Peak if you want a protected trail runner. Compare Trail Glove if you want minimal ground feel. Compare MTL models if performance matters. Compare HOKA Speedgoat, Brooks Cascadia, Salomon Sense Ride, and ASICS trail shoes if you want broader fit and cushioning options.

Internal Next Steps

For another trail replacement, read the Saucony Excursion TR11 guide. For Salomon trail options, read the Salomon X Tour 2 guide. If you are just starting, use the beginner running shoe guide.

FAQ

Is Merrell All Out Rush still worth buying?

Only if it is new, inexpensive, and returnable. Most shoppers should compare current Merrell trail shoes first.

What replaced Merrell All Out Rush?

There is no exact replacement. Merrell Agility Peak, Trail Glove, MTL trail shoes, HOKA Speedgoat, Brooks Cascadia, Salomon Sense Ride, and ASICS trail shoes are useful comparisons.

Can I use All Out Rush on pavement?

You can, but trail shoes are best when your route includes dirt, gravel, rocks, or outdoor surfaces where grip matters.